Harry Alford Today is April 25th, 2017|Hudson Valley Press - More Than News |Bookmark HVPress!

September 25th, 2013

Rotten probation system is just “cash register justice”

Harry C. Alford

Back in the good old days probation was publicly funded. The process was simple and probation officers’ mission was to assist offenders and help them assimilate into the general population. Rehabilitation was the goal - a noble goal indeed. Like our current prison system, probation is no longer about rehabilitation. It has turned into a profit game and recidivism (repeating crime) makes business better. Yes, probation is being privatized and local, state and federal governments no longer have to be responsible for funding the program. The programs are being turned over to private corporations. The funding is coming from the offenders.

Most offenders have lived in poverty for the majority of their life. It is hard, if not impossible, for people living under the poverty level to be able to fund their own probation. This fact makes our new system evil and oppressive. It doesn’t improve our society by rehabilitating our offenders but ensures that the offenders are forever in trouble. The chances of escaping are remote. Being that private probation services are motivated by income, the heavier the caseload the more the revenue. Public probation systems would be overwhelmed and challenged with limited funds. In fact, private agencies have less incentive to report violations of probation as their income would shrink as the offender returns to incarceration.

In Indiana when an offender is released from prison he usually gets a period of house arrest. This is when he has a monitor or bracelet put on his ankle to verify his location. He cannot leave his residence without getting permission and via GPS his movement will be verified. He will be charged $80 per week for the rental of the bracelet. From the very beginning he has a monthly bill of $320. There is a start - up fee of $25. He is required to physically report daily to a downtown office for blood testing (drugs and alcohol). He is charged a $5 daily fee for this. So now, he has a monthly bill of $470 (bracelet and daily fee). Think about this: A person is released with no job and is probably indigent as his family lives in poverty and has no money to assist him. How does he pay that $470 per month?

The US Department of Labor has a few great programs to assist ex-offenders. Congressman Danny Davis (D – IL) has led the charge in assisting offenders as they return to their communities. Employers can be eligible for sizeable tax credits for giving offenders another chance to live a productive life via gainful employment and even a career. The big problem is the programs are hardly enforced or even marketed to the employers. Most don’t know about them or do not know how to process the paper work. Gainful employment is the key to helping offenders get out of this "catch 22". This opportunity sits on a shelf and that is a tragedy.

Periodically he may find a little work. It will be at minimum wage and will definitely be short term. Housing, food and travel back and forth for daily reporting plus the $470 per month becomes an impossible task. When they fall behind in their payments the private probation firm reports it to credit reporting agencies. Broke, under pressure with no permanent job and terrible credit will make most offenders long to go back to prison. Life is totally miserable unless they have friends or relatives that can cover the demands while he serves out his probation. Most don’t make it and return to crime as a means of income. Thus, the recidivism rate is going through the roof in all of our communities.

These private probation firms are making serious money from these offenders. The offenders are like "cash cows" and are treated like chattel or indentured servants. Corruption comes into play also. Having absolute power over the offenders gives the firms the opportunity to even extort more money from the offender. Thus, they are pushing them to find fast cash via criminal activity. Acting on a class-action suit filed in 2010, a judge recently took control of the municipal court of Harpersville, AL, after finding the probation company and the court operated "a judicially-sanctioned extortion racket".

NBC News did a thorough investigation of this activity. They called the private probation transgressions "Cash Register Justice". They also found that Sentinel Offender Services is the largest offender management service in the state of Georgia, collecting more than $30 million in 2009 according to company documents obtained through a public records request.

In terms of corruption, the temptations are immense. One example is a member of the Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles was convicted on public corruption charges for accepting a bribe from a private probation agency. I am certain that this goes on at a rapidly growing rate. America, we need to clean this mess up. People are being hurt.

Harry C. Alford is the co-founder, President and CEO of the National Black Chamber of Commerce.

5 / 5 (1 Votes)

Copyright 2006-2016 The Hudson Valley Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

              Let Your Voice Be Heard ... Fill Out the Reader Response Form Below
Your name:
Your email:
Article Title:
Comment Text:

*Posts do not appear immediately


Are you planning a summer vacation this year?
Not sure



HEADLINES | Copyright © 2006-2016 Hudson Valley Press. All rights reserved. | Use of this site indicates your agreement to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for our Site. |